Key West & the Florida Keys, Florida

Cake & Desserts

In Key West & the Florida Keys: Eight bakers work the chain, five in Key West, two in Key Largo, one in Islamorada. Book the tasting in person if you can, because a video tasting is a compromise that hides texture and moisture, which is what a hot climate rewards the baker for getting right. Confirm delivery in writing, because a cake driven from Key West to Islamorada in August is a real logistics problem: no direct sun, refrigerated transport, and a delivery slot that lands the cake at the venue no more than a couple of hours before service. Ask about coconut, rum, key lime and mango if you want the local answer; ask about traditional buttercream and covered fondant if you want a finish that holds up better on a hundred-degree afternoon than a fresh-fruit topping a mainland baker might recommend.

8 listings · checked August 2026

• Bob's Bunz Bakery & Restaurant — Islamorada · bobsbunz.com · (305) 664-8363
• Cakes By Karol — Key West · cakesbykarol.com · (305) 393-3020
• Key Lime Pie Bakery — Key West · keylimepiebakery.com · (305) 306-8029
• Key West Cakes — Key West · keywestcakes.com · (305) 296-4162
• Keys Chocolates and Ice Cream — Key Largo · keylargochocolates.com · (305) 453-6613
• Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge — Key West · kilwins.com/pages/stores-near-me-key-west-fl-33040-0111 · (305) 320-0986
• Old Town Bakery — Key West · oldtownbakerykeywest.com · (305) 396-7450
• Pinecrest Bakery Online Catering Order — Key Largo · pinecrestbakery.com · (786) 891-3100

Details change constantly — confirm directly before booking. Something wrong? Update or remove a listing.