Milwaukee & Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Catering

In Milwaukee & Lake Geneva: Twelve caterers serve the region. If your reception is in a county park, two things shape the menu before any tasting does. The picnic season runs from the fifteenth of May to the fifteenth of October, so the site is simply not available outside it. And a park site has no kitchen, no shade you did not bring and often no power, which turns a plated dinner into a logistics question rather than a menu one. Ask what the caterer needs brought in and who is paying to bring it. Capacity at a county picnic area is calculated at eight people per table, so your headcount and your table count are the same conversation. Budget $65 to $140 a head, and confirm whether tax and service charge sit inside the quote or on top of it.

12 listings · checked August 2026

• Bartolotta Catering at Discovery World — Milwaukee · bartolottas.com/catering/discovery-world · (414) 765-8610
• CAFA B DATA by Mosaic — Whitefish Bay · cateringbymosaic.com · (414) 967-8225
• Catering by Danny — Mount Pleasant · cateringbydanny.com · (262) 417-7510
• Celebration on Wells — Lake Geneva · celebrationonwells.com · (262) 248-2555
• Charlies Catering & Co — South Milwaukee · charliescateringcompany.com · (414) 570-7500
• Chef David's Catered Events — Kenosha · chefdavids.com · (262) 748-1171
• Davians — Menomonee Falls · davians.com · (262) 781-8507
• Emerald City Catering & Events — Milwaukee · emeraldcitycatering.com · (414) 672-3434
• Prime Minister Restaurant and Catering — Thiensville · pmcatering.com · (262) 238-1530
• Saz's Catering — Milwaukee · sazs.com · (414) 256-8765
• Shully's Cuisine and Events — Thiensville · shullyscuisine.com · (262) 242-6633
• Tall Guy and a Grill Catering — West Allis · tallguyandagrill.com · (414) 777-0770

Details change constantly — confirm directly before booking. Something wrong? Update or remove a listing.