Milwaukee & Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Wedding Rings

In Milwaukee & Lake Geneva: Twelve jewelers are listed and they spread across the western suburbs and the lakeshore towns rather than clustering downtown, so it is worth more than one appointment on the same custom work. Give two to three months for sizing, engraving and anything custom. Sizing carries a seasonal wrinkle in a climate this extreme: hands measured in a January that averages a high of thirty-one degrees are not the hands you will have at a July reception. Ask to be sized closer to your wedding season, or ask the jeweler to account for it. Budget $800 to $4,000, and ask who handles resizing and repairs afterward, because that is the relationship that outlasts the wedding by decades.

12 listings · checked August 2026

• Armbruster Jewelers — Cedarburg · armbrusterjewelers.com · (262) 377-0480
• Cival Jewelry & Design Studio — Milwaukee · shopcival.com · (414) 394-0355
• David Liska Custom Jeweler — Mequon · davidliskacustomjeweler.com · (414) 331-6568
• Kesslers Diamonds — Brookfield · kesslersdiamonds.com · (414) 721-9450
• Lake Country Jewelers Ltd — Pewaukee · lakecountryjewelers.com · (262) 695-9028
• Plumb Gold — Racine · plumbgoldjewelry.com · (262) 632-5022
• Powers Jewelry Designers — Milwaukee · milwaukee-jewelry.com · (414) 272-4510
• Rogers & Hollands — Wauwatosa · rogersandhollands.com/mayfair-mall · (414) 607-9700
• Shallow Jewelers — West Allis · shallowjewelers.com · (414) 476-1553
• Sullivan Jewelers — Brookfield · sullivanjewelers.com · (262) 641-2995
• Tobin Jewelers Mequon — Mequon · tobinjewelers.com · (262) 789-8451
• Wyndrose Fine Jewelry — Cedarburg · wyndrosefinejewelry.com · (262) 375-1920

Details change constantly — confirm directly before booking. Something wrong? Update or remove a listing.